C-I-A-E valuation: how Simson Desk scores what an asset is worth protecting
ISO 27001 asks you to know which of your assets matter most. The usual method rates each one for confidentiality, integrity and availability. Simson Desk adds a fourth objective, and then makes the rating do some work.
The four objectives
| Objective | The question it asks |
|---|---|
| Confidentiality | What happens if this is seen by someone who should not see it? |
| Integrity | What happens if this is wrong or altered? |
| Availability | What happens if this is not there when needed? |
| Expectations | What have customers, regulators or the law been promised about it? |
Each is rated High, Moderate or Low.
Why “expectations” is separate
The first three measure damage. The fourth measures commitment. A system may cause little harm if it is down for a day, yet a customer contract may promise that it will not be. A register that holds personal data carries a statutory duty whatever its business value. Expectations are rated on the strength of that commitment — a contract or service level, a legal duty, a certification requirement.
How the result is worked out
- The security category is the highest of the four ratings. One High makes the item High.
- The score is the weighted average of the four, with High as 3, Moderate as 2 and Low as 1.
- The score falls into a band: Low, Moderate or High.
Where it applies
- Assets: each item type has default ratings, which can be overridden for a single asset.
- Vendors: availability defaults from how critical the vendor is.
- Information assets: the classification sets a minimum for confidentiality, so restricted information cannot be rated Low.
What the rating then does
This is the part most spreadsheets lack. When a risk or an incident is linked to an asset, a vendor or an information asset, the rating sets a floor. A risk against a High item cannot be given a trivial impact. An incident touching one cannot be logged as minor without a written reason. If the rating of the item changes later, the floors are applied again.
Why an auditor likes it
The method is written down, the same in every register, and its results are visible in the risks and incidents it governs. The auditor can pick any asset and follow the rating into the decisions it shaped.
- What does the E in C-I-A-E stand for?
- Expectations: what customers, regulators and the law expect of you for that item.
- How is the overall category decided?
- It is the highest of the four ratings.
- Can I change the default ratings?
- Yes. Defaults are set per item type and can be overridden per asset.